General
p/general
Share and discuss anything tech, products, business, or startup-related
Natallia Shakhmetava
What do you think about higher education, is it necessary these days?
Featured
185
Recently, we have a discussion about that topic with few friends, I am curious to know what the tech community thinks about this.
Replies
Best
Murali Gottumukkala
Education is increasing awareness and ensuring you learn things like collaboration, planning, research and analyzing skills. So it is entirely dependent on the person as what experiences they have in their life to come to a decision whether they need education at all.
Rich Watson
it used to be "it's not what you know, it's who you know" and it still is very much like that indie devs with no schooling can be just as successful, if they have the right idea and/or team- or a solid leader to partner with
Swapnil D Puranik
Wow! there's a lot being said here.. and I haven't gone through the earlier replies. But - my view is a big NO! I have been actively pushing my cousins and younger folks in neighbourhood to take an academic break or push their Graduate studies by a year or two - instead work in a startup or learn new skills and build shit. Academia is fast losing relevance in our today and tomorrow.
Daniyar Yeskaliyev
I thought that it wasn't that necessary because I got Bachelor's in Radio Engineering and Master's in PM / Business. But then my PM degree has helped me numerous times - to launch my business, and drive project-based initiatives in every company I worked for. Also, having a master's degree has helped me immigrate to Canada, because academic degree do count - at they weight a lot - in official evaluations of your 'human capital' worth. Then, Knowledge from my Tech Degree has helped me nail learning programming in just 6 months. How? Because I've studied the hardware - everything about Electronics, Semi-conductors and Transistor logic. We used to design (on paper) the Analog-Digital and Digital-Analog convertors, and Transistor logic devices, and Transistor storage devices. Which all is Computer Science, but even on the deeper level then taught in Comp Science classes (at least 90% of Comp Science grads didn't know what I knew about the physical layer). Not to mention CISCO standard courses for Computer Networking. It all helped me get credibility for all of the job interviews, my current employer is also a PhD in Radio Engineering, so he even asked me some of Radio 101 questions during the interview - and he was impressed that I remember than stuff 7 years after graduation. That was a sign for him of my overall intellectual development, and academic degrees are a sign of quality. Yeah, there are many ways to get these degrees without learning anything, but it's the best mean for credibility that we have. And maybe elite professional certifications can count, too, like Financial (CPA, CFA, FRM), PM (PMP), CISCO, Microsoft etc. But I would learn any of that if it wasn't for the University, and to be honest, I did like 40% of my potential in school because I loved missing classes, hanging out with friends instead of learning and was overall very lazy (smart, but lazy) student. To sum up, higher education can be dodged, but if you're not from a developer country - you really want to consider getting the highest degree possible in order to increase your Mobility on the International Market.
Kate Dalessi
Depends on what you want to do with your life. If you want to be a doctor, hell yes it's necessary! As far as IT goes, however, I think no educational institution is adaptive enough to be able to catch up with the tempo things are changing here.
Software Guy (Aarvy)
It's not necessary, it totally depends upon the person doing it. This is skill based economy so more weightage should be toward how much you know rather thank how much you have studied.
Anne-Laure Le Cunff
As someone who's been a long-time advocate for self-education but decided to go back to university at age 28, I think the answer is quite nuanced. Some basics need to be covered: good communication, project management, learning how to learn, etc. Which, ironically, are often not covered that well in traditional higher education, but are still touched upon through group projects and such. Once the basics are covered, there are many kinds of roles where you'll learn much better on your own and on the job than you would by going to university. This is especially true of fast-changing areas like web development and online marketing. I think anyone who's motivated can do these jobs very well by using a combination of online courses and having a good manager that can provide mentorship. But there are some kinds of jobs where you still do need formal tutoring and access to specific resources through higher education. That includes any kind of job that relates to people's health and safety, such as medical staff, but also jobs where you need to be trained with specialist equipment that you may not have available at home. That's why I went back to school to study neuroscience – no way I could afford an MRI scanner and put it in my living room! So, it depends on the kind of role you're looking at. In many cases, higher education is not only unnecessary, but is a bad choice when you consider the opportunity costs.
Natallia Shakhmetava
@anthilemoon, wow, that's really hard to combine work and education! Good luck with that) Thank you for your opinion and link to tool with opportunity costs)
Chetan Natesh
We are definitely in a skill based economy, so a degree makes sense only for a few particular professions like law, medicine etc. So by higher education if you mean degree then they are not as essential as before. But definitely upskilling has to be given very high priority.
Ishwar Jha
Education is and education will always be necessary throughout. All the guys who complain about education are those who've achieved significant milestones in their life through education. Try to read people who've become rich and famous without education and somewhere they would have mentioned "I wish I would have studied."
Satish Kumar Veluri
If we are talking about higher education as in going to college, then the necessity is based on persona - people who do it because of their passion for learning - people who do it for fulfilling a criteria If it's not about going to college, then there are tons and tons of people who learn things which matter their progress (both in professionally and personally).
Natallia Shakhmetava
@satish_kumar_veluri, thank you! Yeah, about going to college, unfortunately, there are a lot of people, who go there just because it's the right thing to do
Satish Kumar Veluri
@shakhmetava_natallia I'm not really sure about the "right thing to do" feeling..😁 I see people doing it just because lot's of other people are doing it. It's like buying a product in amazon or flipkart based on the reviews 😁
Steven Birchall
Necessary, I'd say no, but still very useful for those who choose to do it. For those who can get experience without it, they usually will be fine in their careers, especially in the tech space where skills and experience are more important.
Martin Moravek
It depends on the profession/career. If you want to be a medical doctor, it would be suitable to have a formal education (especially to have a licence). 😄 On the other hand, I know many people (programmers, marketers etc.) who don't have higher education and are very good at their mission. Many people earn their education by practising, reading books, and connecting with other people in the professional area. Higher education can help us make connections that can be valuable in the future. It is an investment in our relationships.
Natallia Shakhmetava
@minimalistphone, thank you for sharing! I completely agree that it depends on the specialty in the first place and there are many options for learning without going to college. What do you think of those companies that require higher education?
Martin Moravek
@shakhmetava_natallia Honestly, I do not know what to think about them, because some of them require tremendous skills and higher education, but their salary evaluation does not correspond to the requirements. That's one of the many reasons I run my own business. In many cases, companies do not want to pay more because you are "too qualified". Also, it depends on countries. There are many factors that step into the game, such as culture and social status.
Csaba Zajdo
Higher education is crucial these days. It is the time in which I develop my critical thinking skills and broaden my horizons.
Tibor Szantai
Higher education is an essential and helpful tool in the modern world. It gives you a wide range of opportunities, but it also has disadvantages.
Doğu Gül
From speaking about the viewpoint of technical knowledge, it may not be necessary to learn specific courses that may not be useful in work practices. However, some of the skills can be applied to the profession directly, depending on your job. I think the most important thing about higher education is that it teaches you how to think.
Natallia Shakhmetava
@dogu.gul thank you for your opinion, yes, I agree that the most important thing about higher education is that it teaches you how to think
Maxime Néau
In my opinion books are the best education of all and can replace most costly higher education courses. The ones you pick out of genuine intellectual interest are the best
Andrew James Bagby
Important for friends, connections, opportunities, and life experiences you wouldn't otherwise encounter. As far as hard skills, it's very specific to your major. Some yes, some not at all.
Jason Curry
I think there's a great need for vocational (job specific) training. If you go to college you gain knowledge, theory and critical thinking skills. Vocation training provides a bit of that, but instead focuses on practical, actionable skill acquisition which can get you a job in a few months. And often times these jobs pay more than traditional careers you might get if you did complete college. Excluding of course things like medicine, law, aerospace engineering, etc :)
Natallia Shakhmetava
@jasonacurry thank you, definitely in college you gain knowledge, theory and critical thinking skills
Angel Gutiérrez Pizarro
I think that in some careers, especially business-related, higher education as it is known today will not last long. But higher education still has a key role in our society and there are careers where it will always be there, it will iterate, but it will be there. Careers related to science, medicine, etc You don´t want self-made doctor, don't you? Like it always happens nothing is white or black.
Igor Sadkin
In the past, I have thought that higher education was necessary in order to be successful in life. I think that education is necessary for a person to learn how to work and live in a society