Subscribe
Sign in
Start new thread
p/seed-2
Store and validate your ideas in one place 💡
Visit Product
JohnathanK
Seed — Store and validate your ideas in one place 💡
Featured
20
•

Seed allows you to store and validate your ideas. You can browse through the seed feed to give feedback to other users' ideas.

Replies
Kyle Richey
Cool idea. It’d be awesome if in addition to ratings for Originality & Difficulty there was one for Value. e.g. The Beard Attachments one might be very original and low difficulty, but its value is debatable. 😉
Nathan Green
@imakestrides that's an interesting one. The value part might be tricky to evaluate by the publisher. Might be equivalent to the number of lightbulbs 😉?
Ebrahim-Khalil Hassen
Good luck. Have added Seed as a recommendation on this question. https://www.producthunt.com/ask/...
Haoyang Feng
Pretty good platform. The UI is clean too. The font on the top filter bar is a bit too small.. At least on ubuntu.
Yann
Having to sign up in order to use the search/filter? That must be the biggest growth-hack I've seen so far this year 😁
Primer
@yannschaub or the biggest barrier to entry?
Nathan Green
@yannschaub it's actually an implementation mistake :P we are getting rid of it.
JJ Coleman
Looks nice! Is there a way to unvote? I've clicked on a vote "light bulb" on accident, there doesn't seem to me a way to undo that, on mobile at least.
Razvan Gabriel

I enjoy surfing your feed in order to scout for interesting ideas or find something that would spark a little brainstorming session in my mind. One thing you could do is think about the privacy of the idea. What gives the maker/thinker the trust that his/her idea won't be stolen if it is a good one? Even if the maker recognizes the threat when posting, some kind of an NDA functionality or similar should be implemented. Also you can think about privding a way for people to contact the publisher of the idea to facilitate finding co-founders or people who would offer to work on the same idea.

Pros:

Great place submit for feedback or surf for interesting ideas!

Cons:

Will need more testing but maybe privacy for ideas and UX?

Nathan Green
@razgraf thank you for the feedback. The privacy issue is an interesting one. The original idea was to publish and get feedback asap. Having an NDA in place before viewing an idea might reduce the likelihood of someone giving out feedback. Then again, we will need to play around with it. Connecting people to work on the idea is a great idea!
Hugh HipsdontLie Roberts
Yeah, needs more privacy so you don't share some of your ideas.
Nathan Green
@road_2015 we are looking into integration with the twitter account. Any other suggestion regarding the privacy?
Nathan Green
@hugh_hipsdontlie_roberts what do you think is a good solution to the privacy issue?
Hugh HipsdontLie Roberts
@johnkuorevy I wanted to actually test using it with my team... like invite everyone from my office and we track our ideas in one place and give feedback in that way... but found out it was public. These are business ideas and don't want our competition seeing them, so best to keep them where we have them for now.
Primer
Was enjoying scrolling through the ideas. Decided to search. Was told I needed to register. To search.... Closed the app and will never be back.
Ognjen Vukovic
This is nice! I like the idea. Wish you all the luck! :)
Vlad Korobov
@frantzlight Do you have tags to mark ideas? With what tech did you do the search?
Nathan Green
@frantzlight @vladkorobov no tags at the moment. would consider implementing it if it's well received. Elastic search.